| 2007/08 Wednesfield FC 3v2 AFC Wulfrunians | 1964/65 Whitmore Old Boys v Chubbs |
| 2006/07 Wyrley Rangers v Darlaston T. | 1963/64 Stewarts & Lloyds v Oxley |
| 2005/06 Great Wyrley v Wyrley Juniors | 1962/63 Highley Miners v Stewarts & Lloyds |
| 2004/05 Great Wyrley v Parkfield Leisure | 1964/65 Whitmore Old Boys v Chubbs |
| 2003/04 Great Wyrley v Cadbury Ath | 1963/64 Stewarts & Lloyds v Oxley |
| 2002/03 Old Wulfrunians v Newport T | 1962/63 Highley Miners v Stewarts & Lloyds |
| 2001/02 Marston Wolves v Ounsdale | 1961/62 Madeley Miners v E.C.C. |
| 2000/01 Ounsdale v Old Wulfrunians | 1960/61 Whitmore Old Boys v Madeley Miners |
| 1999/00 Continental Star v Old Wulfrunians | 1959/60 Wednesbury Tube v Donnington Wood |
| 1998/99 Blackheath Electrodrives v Brownhills T | 1958/59 Donnington Wood v Sankey (Hadley) |
| 1997/98 Tamworth v Brownhills T | 1957/58 Jenks & Catell v Donnington Wood |
| 1996/97 Richmond Swifts v Cheslyn Hay | 1956/57 Claregate Old Boys v Sankey (Hadley) |
| 1995/96 Richmond Swifts v Handrahan Timbers | 1955/56 Sankey (Hadley) v Marandola |
| 1994/95 Richmond Swifts v Aero Lucas | 1954/55 Sankey (Hadley) v Willenhall T |
| 1993/94 Walsall Phoenix v Handrahan Timbers | 1953/54 Marandola v Sankey (Hadley) |
| 1992/93 Handrahan Timbers v Old Wulfrunians | 1952/53 Goodyear FC v Low Hill A.M.T. |
| 1991/92 Old Wulfrunians v Nucoat | 1951/52 Goodyear FC v Gibbons Bros. |
| 1990/91 Bilston Comm College v Enville Ath | 1950/51 Goodyear FC v Bushbury Hill Rgers |
| 1989/90 Shifnal T v Goodyear FC | 1949/50 Staff Road Works v Oxley |
| 1988/89 Bloxwich Strollers v Toll End, Wesley | 1948/49 Lower Gornal v Walsall Wood |
| 1987/88 Weston United v Plough Inn, Trysull | 1947/48 Walsall T v Stafford Road Works |
| 1986/87 Harvey Plant FC v Plough Inn, Trysull | 1946/47 C. Snapes v W'ton Tech College |
| 1985/86 Deeleys FC v Handrahan Timbers | 1945/46 Oxley v Blakenhall Heath |
| 1984/85 Lower Gornal YL v Tipton Sports | 1944/45 Oxley v C. Snapes |
| 1983/84 Ettingshall Holy T v Lower Gornal YL | 1943/44 Oxley v Blakenhall St. Lukes |
| 1982/83 Ettingshall Holy T v Astra International | 1942/43 Coley Hay v Union Locks |
| 1981/82 New World v Kingswinford United | 1941/42 Butlers Sports v Oxley |
| 1980/81 John Thompsons v Coseley Royal | 1940/41 Albion Works v R.A.F. Cosford |
| 1979/80 Kingswinford United v Ettingshall Holy T | 1939/40 Yale & T v Wolverhampton Amats |
| 1978/79 Sedgley Rovers v Tranco United | 1938/39 Essington St. John v C & B Smith |
| 1977/78 Willenhall T v Wolverhampton United | 1937/38 Goodyear FC v Albion Works |
| 1976/77 Wolverhampton United v Groveland | 1936/37 Heath T United v Goodyear F.C |
| 1975/76 Manders FC v Anslow Ath | 1935/36 Short Heath United v Goodyear F.C |
| 1974/75 Whitmore Old Boys v Willenhall T | 1934/35 Streetly Works v Essington St. John |
| 1973/74 Northicote Old Boys v John Harpers | 1933/34 Streetly Works 3-1 West End W.M.C. |
| 1972/73 Wednesfield T v Willenhall T | 1932/33 Blakenhall Villa 4-2 Walsall Wood |
| 1971/72 Wednesfield T v Manders FC | 1931/32 Short Heath United 2-1 Goodyear F.C |
| 1970/71 Willenhall T v Whitmore Old Boys | 1930/31 Hickmans I 5-1 Cannon Iron |
| 1969/70 Wednesfield Social v Guy Motors | 1929/30 Short Heath United 2-1 Hickmans I |
| 1968/69 Public Works v Duport | 1928/29 Tarmac 5-0 Chillingtons Ath |
| 1967/68 Albrighton v Northicote Old Boys | 1927/28 Tarmac 4-2 Lane Head United |
| 1966/67 Gibbons Bros. v Public Works | 1926/27 Short Heath United 2-0 Cannon Iron |
| 1965/66 Albrighton v Oxley | |
